Mystic Pines
Torrey Pine Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Mystic Pines Community
home_pin
Torrey Pine Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706 | Suffolk county
Mystic Pines is a thoughtfully designed condominium and townhome community located in Bay Shore, offering a welcoming and versatile living environment that appeals to a wide range of lifestyles. Built between 2005 and 2006, this intimate community of approximately 90 homes is known for its park-like setting, well-planned layout, and peaceful residential feel. Tree-lined lanes and neatly maintained grounds create a sense of calm and pride of ownership, making Mystic Pines feel like a true neighborhood rather than just a place to live.
What makes Mystic Pines especially unique is its inclusive design. The community is thoughtfully divided to accommodate both residents of all ages and an active 55+ section. While the homes share the same attractive floor plans and finishes, the 55+ residences include elevator access to all levels, offering added convenience and long-term comfort. Homes are two-story townhouses with basements, featuring spacious interiors, central air conditioning, gas heating, attached garages, and private backyard patios, ideal for everyday living, entertaining, or simply enjoying quiet moments outdoors.
Mystic Pines enjoys a prime South Shore location close to village shopping, major roadways, and public transportation. With easy access to the Long Island Railroad and nearby parkways, commuting to New York City or traveling across Long Island is straightforward and convenient, while still allowing residents to enjoy a relaxed suburban atmosphere.
6,171 sq.ft.
Average Lot Size
0
Active Listings
91
Total Housing Units
1,616
Average Square Footage
Resident Amenities
pool
Pool
fitness_center
Fitness Center
family_group
Clubhouse
chair_fireplace
Lounge
Schedule a visit
Select when you would like to go to visit.
What time?
or
Learn the Mystic Pines Story
Schedule a visit
Select when you would like to go to visit.
What time?
or
Resident Amenities
expand_lessInteractive Map
Mystic Pines Community (and nearby)Mystic Pines Residences
Data loading...
Active Listings & Homes For Sale and For Rent
| Photo | Lot | Price | Beds | Baths | Square Feet | HOA Fees | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading listings data... | |||||||
Recent Activity at The Mystic Pines Community
| Date | Lot | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loading activity data... | |||
Floorplans
Loading floorplans…
Community Facts
- Community Name: Mystic Pines
- Neighborhood: Bay Shore
- Year Established: 2001
- Total Homes: 91 residences
- Property Type: Townhomes
- County: Suffolk county
- Available Sales Listings: 0
- Available Rental Listings: 0
- Lifestyle & HOA: Life at Mystic Pines is designed to be easy, social, and low-maintenance. The homeowners association plays an important role in preserving the beauty and functionality of the community, maintaining the landscaped grounds and shared amenities so residents can focus on enjoying their homes and surroundings. The community clubhouse serves as a welcoming hub, offering space to gather with neighbors, host activities, or simply unwind. A gym and outdoor swimming pool provide opportunities to stay active and healthy without leaving the neighborhood. Mystic Pines is pet-friendly, adding to its warm and inclusive atmosphere, and fostering a sense of connection among neighbors. The HOA structure supports a carefree lifestyle, making it especially appealing to those who value convenience without sacrificing space or comfort. Beyond the community itself, residents enjoy a vibrant lifestyle thanks to Mystic Pines’ proximity to the Great South Bay. Beaches, marinas, waterfront parks, and boating destinations are just minutes away, as are golf courses, country clubs, and scenic outdoor spaces. Bay Shore’s lively Main Street offers restaurants, boutiques, cultural events, and seasonal festivals that bring the community together throughout the year. With excellent access to shopping centers, parks, and everyday necessities, Mystic Pines offers a balanced lifestyle, peaceful at home, yet connected to everything Bay Shore has to offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Learn more about the Mystic Pines community and available homes for sale and rent here in Bay Shore.
When was Mystic Pines built?
Mystic Pines was built in 2001.
Where is Mystic Pines located?
Mystic Pines is located at Torrey Pine Lane in Bay Shore in NY.
What amenities does the Mystic Pines community provide?
Mystic Pines provides the following resident amenities: Pool, Fitness Center, Clubhouse, Lounge.
What county is Mystic Pines located in?
Mystic Pines is located in Suffolk county.
How many homes are currently available in Mystic Pines for sale or for rent?
Out of 91 homes in Mystic Pines, there are currently 0 sales listings and 0 rental listings available.
What is the average square footage in the Mystic Pines community?
The average square footage of homes in Mystic Pines is 1616 sq.ft.
How big is the Mystic Pines community?
The Mystic Pines community is made up of 91 homes with an average lot size of 6170 sq.ft.
Schedule a Visit
Ask a Question
Join Waitlist
Sign up to get community updates
Subscribe to property updates
Sign up to join the waitlist!
Subscribe to property updates